“In all its roles and appearances, improvisation can be considered as the celebration of the moment. And in this the nature of improvisation exactly resembles the nature of music. Essentially, music is fleeting: its reality is its moment of performance.”
+Improvisation.jpg)
I danced for years with several performance groups. We always improvised during practice or choreography -- either fooling around, showing off, or fleshing out movements for piece. The only time I EVER thought it was appropriate to improvise during performance was if you royally screwed up. My instructors always said, “Perform your mistake,” which boiled down to improvise, get back in the show, and look good doing it. This was something you hoped you never had to do. Anyway, I never thought we were actually improvising anything. We seemed to always just be creatively building upon various sets of choreographed movements that had been drilled in our heads for years, with a bit of panache and tweaks here and there.
Then, while performing in winterguard, we had a world-class dance choreographer, Octavio Campos, come work with us for a day. He was all about improv. Most us were terrified. The first thing he did was split us into 6 person groups and gave us each a theme. My group's theme was “a food fight.” We had a few seconds to think it over, then we were on stage, told to dance as a group to our theme, no rules, no limits. It was so freeing and mindblowing. Who thought an improvised dance based on a food fight would allow us to realize the potential we had to let loose, invent new movements, tap into inner feelings, and really respond with our bodies, that we had been training for years, with new creative expression. We also got a good laugh out of the whole experience.
“A lot of improvisers find improvisation worthwhile, I think, because of the possibilities. Things that can happen but perhaps rarely do. One of those things is that you are ‘taken out of yourself’” (Bailey, 1992, p.115).
Since I don’t play an instrument, I have to recall experiences like this in order to understand the enigmatic nature of improvisation. I love how Bailey says that improvisation exists “to meet the creative appetite that is the natural part of being a performing musician” and invites creative participation in music making (Bailey, 1992, p. 142). After reading through Derek Bailey’s book, it seems that improvisation seems to defy definition. I’m beginning to think about it as a philosophical debate! Improvisation in any nature seems inherent in all of us. Some may be able to improvise while cooking, in comedy, acting, in debates, on term papers, dancing, painting. Improv seems to come at that moment that we spring out of the box, celebrate the moment, see all the possibilities, and flow how naturally feel like flowing.

Bailey’s section on “Audience” was particularly interesting. I can claim to being an audience member at several music performance. Bailey quotes musicians who that practice is when the true improvisation happens because they’re not worries about an audience (Bailey, 1992, p.45). While other say the audience is what pumps them up, when you improvise you are communicating to the audience, and no matter how fantastic you play, if there is no audience “it doesn’t mean anything” (Bailey, 1992, p. 45). Jerry Garcia suggests that you have to train the audience, they become involved and emotional connected to the musician offering them a special moment, something different from recorded music.
Two “Improv” Musicians I recognize as re-defining improvisation
ANDREW BIRD and GIRL TALK
I am a HUGE fan of the musician Andrew Bird. One of the primary reasons is that he always offers up something new - his sounds are innovative - and he never plays a song the same way when performing live. Because of this class I am learning to appreciate his music even more. I have mentioned his improvisation skills in my Week 6 blog entry:
“The most appealing aspect of Andrew Bird’s music is that his live performances are never the same. Every song is played differently, with new twists, new instruments, extended, re-looped, and maybe involving the audience. At an Andrew Bird concert you are guaranteed some of the familiar with the excitement of something new and tantalizing to keep you interested.”
On page 169, Levitin says, "Music is organized sound, but the organization has to involved some element of of the unexpected or it is emotionally flat and robotic." This is so true of improvisation and Andrew Bird's music. It is definitely worth checking out his unnatural whistling skills in his songs!
Andrew Bird's revealing NY Times blog about the process of making music:
“I’m trying to get over this mental block I have against the validity of instrumental music. I think this tension between craft and experimental, improvisatory indulgence is healthy. My wariness toward “jamming” is based on years playing in listless jazz combos where everyone pulls out their real books and plays “Song for my Father” or
“Equinox” for the umpteenth time. That feeling of futility just became too much for me to bear. After getting tendonitis in the summer of my 22nd year playing jigs and reels for Dungeons and Dragons enthusiasts as they waited in line for the privy at a southern Wisconsin Renaissance Faire, I swore I wouldn’t associate that sort of futility with music again. A decade later, I’m loosening those reins a bit.”
From a Seattle Times article about Bird's music:
While Bird's albums are painstakingly crafted ("My approach to recording is like a long, drawn-out performance where I go into the studio for four days, hardly eat, hardly sleep, never take a break to lose focus"), his performances teeter on improvisational daring. They're captivating: Either solo or backed by a small band, Bird sings and plucks and whistles that strange, mournful whistle while simultaneously operating a digital looping machine with his feet.
"Myself and everyone I play with come from more like a restless jazz background and we have to stimulate ourselves otherwise we feel really bad about ourselves," he laughs. "If you play a show where everything went according to plan, you feel like you're letting yourself down. You really wanna get that flush of almost embarrassment-slash-rush from having tried something risky."
Then there's Girl Talk – mash up, DJ mixmaster genius Gregg Gillis – who gets crowds going crazy by simply mixing music on two laptops duct taped to a folding table on stage. It is my goal in life to see how he organizes his massive library of music samples and produces explosive 3-5 minute mash ups of music from the
80’s, 90’s, and today. For example, he has blended Big Country, Tag Team’s “Whoomp! There it is!,” The Cardigans, Flo Rida, Justin Timberlake, Velvet Underground, Janet Jackson, and Genesis into a 4 minute mash up called “Hands in the Air!” (I have heard this song played at least 5 different ways already).

If anything, you are guaranteed to never see the same Girl Talk show. Even though he has recorded albums and may use similar song compilations at shows – it’s always a surprise where he will go with it. Many critics say that Girl Talk is not an artist or musician. But I will defend him – just imagine how many hours he spent entrenched organizing, compiling, and mixing samples – that’s art. Not to mention, I will pay $10-$20 anyday for a high energy Girl Talk show, than $50+ to listen to some pretentious band play the same songs over and over again.
And how does the live act compare to the record, I wonder. I mean, can we expect the same mash-ups we’ve come to know and love at the Laneway Festival and his sideshow at the Forum?
“The transitions are basically improvised every night, how I go from one segment to the next. I never really replicate that. But with the actual combination of songs, I never really want it to be something I’m improvising. Because for me the art of what I’m doing – it’s not like I hear a Duran Duran song that I like and then immediately it clicks what that’s gonna go with – it’s a very long trial and error process. I sit there and try out many different combinations and then that goes into the show. I’ll probably know that say these three songs go together and then these next four songs go together, but how I actually execute it, when I drop the beat, when I bring in the sample, every night that changes up.”


No comments:
Post a Comment